Dutch pension funds are showing interest in investing in young companies. This is good news for innovative startups and scale-ups, as there is high demand for venture capital. This is also true in the Northern Netherlands, where there is a strong focus on innovative market sectors. But: venture capital and pension funds? Don’t those two clash? That’s true, says Anton Kramer, fund manager at the Groningen Investment Fund; risk management is still the guiding principle. But there are signs pointing toward change.
“PME* is investing hundreds of millions in Dutch high-tech startups. PMT* and PFZW* have made or announced substantial investments in Dutch and European innovation. And ABP* has set aside 10 billion for Dutch impact investments. “Large pension funds are clearly more active in European venture capital investments than in the past,” Kramer states. “They want to invest closer to home, in the local economy.” This is partly due to sometimes critical questions from fund participants, who want to know what happens to their contributions. “Take, for example, the debate over investing in fossil fuels. Recently, the geographic component has become increasingly relevant. Independence from China—and now also from the United States—has significantly boosted the importance of investments in European innovation. The trend toward deglobalization calls for using our own capital for our own innovation. The Wennink report also advocates for investments in our own economy. Pension funds are well aware of the need for this.”
Scale is a challenge
Kramer does, however, warn against excessive optimism. Funding startups and scale-ups often involves relatively small amounts. So it seems like a simple calculation. After all, given the staggering assets of Dutch pension funds—over €1,600 billion—what they’re asking for is small change. Yet that is precisely where the problem lies. “To achieve a sufficient investment volume, pension funds would have to invest time and energy in a great many startups. That is out of proportion to the contribution to the total return. Based on that observation, various initiatives have been launched to help pension funds invest in venture capital. Invest-NL is working on its own fund of substantial size to eliminate the administrative burden for pension funds. Limiting the scope to a single region also increases the risk: a scope that is too narrow limits the potential and thus creates vulnerability.”
According to Kramer, pension funds will therefore not focus specifically on the Northern Netherlands; rather, investments will be made on a national scale. This can still have a strongly positive impact on opportunities for regional startups and scale-ups. What may be a relatively modest investment for a pension fund could be the decisive factor in their success. “Moreover, with scale-ups, the concept has already been validated in the market. That makes them potentially attractive to pension funds.” But scale-ups, in particular, are finding it difficult to secure funding, as both the FD and De Volkskrant recently reported. This means that their growth into the market is stalling. “I do recognize that signal,” says Kramer. “The biggest risk may be out of the way, but scaling up often requires more capital than in the startup phase.”
Energy, deep tech, and health as impact sectors
Kramer sees growing interest among pension funds, particularly in sectors with a significant social impact. “Pension funds regularly conduct research into what their members value—sustainability, for example, or local impact. That makes the investments meaningful to the members.” The Northern Netherlands in general, and Groningen in particular, offer sectors that are attractive to pension funds, including the energy transition, deep tech such as AI, and healthcare. “Healthcare, for example, is a sector where you can make a significant impact. Innovations in healthcare or in medicines are very valuable, but also very costly. A great deal of money is needed for research before a product is approved for the market, so that sector benefits greatly from large investors.”
The trend toward deglobalization calls for using one’s own capital to fuel innovation.
Anton Kramer NOM
IFG as a Lever for the North
The NOM, as well as funds in which the IFG participates, often invest in companies during their early stages. In doing so, the IFG applies the fund-of-funds principle. Together with other well-capitalized parties, such a fund gains sufficient scale and can act as a kind of lever. “Through our contacts with fund managers, we can attract interest to the Northern Netherlands and to Groningen. Many companies need new capital to continue growing. The northern economy will thus also benefit from pension funds’ investments in venture capital.” Kramer adds one more point: “A successful scale-up requires more than just funding; the company must also be ready in other areas to take the next step. This is where the NOM plays its important role for the Northern Netherlands.”
Groningen Investment Fund (IFG).
The Groningen Investment Fund (IFG) is managed by NOM and invests in investment funds that, in turn, can invest their capital in startups and scale-ups in the province of Groningen. Based on this “fund-of-funds” principle, the fund aims to achieve two types of returns: financial and social.
*PME = Metal and Technology Pension Fund
PMT = Metal and Technology Pension Fund
PFZW = Healthcare and Welfare Pension Fund
ABP = General Civil Service Pension Fund